audit: search, AI readiness & on-site ux

Why 150,000 keywords vanished, and what to do about it

Read to learn how my proprietary audit uncovered why 150,000 keywords disappeared for a large industrial distributor, and the strategy I recommended to recover lost search visibility.

This is an anonymized, but real, audit built the same way I'd run one for a new client. It shows the methodology and tooling behind how I diagnose off-site search performance, score AI readiness with my proprietary crawler, and evaluate on-site search & UX.

The subject: an industrial distributor (anonymized as "Client," benchmarked against "Comp 1" and "Comp 2"), turned around in one week.

1 week
Turnaround
3
audit tracks: seo, ai (aeo/geo/ucp), ux
-40% drop
in ranked keywords
01
diagnose
Organic visibility
Benchmark traffic and rankings against two largest competitors to find where and why visibility dropped.
02
score
AI readiness
Crawl product pages with a proprietary tool and score structured data against AI/agent commerce signals.
03
evaluate
On-site search & UX
Test real search scenarios on desktop and mobile to surface friction in filtering and results.
04
recommend
Executive recommendations
A staged plan across both funnel stages, prioritized by impact and effort.
The findings  ·   Benchmarked vs 2 competitors

A visibility gap, not a product gap

the smoking gun
Traffic Share
Client
9%
Comp 1
38%
Comp 2
52%
Keyword overlap
Client
9%
Comp 1
38%
Comp 2
52%
Products google can't find

A sample of high-volume terms where Client ranks poorly while both competitors are consistently ranked near the top (smaller number is better).

Keyword
Vol / mo
Client
Comp 1
Comp 2
screw
33.1K
0
10
30
c-clamp
27.1K
0
32
6
carbide drill bits
8.1K
43
15
9
pressure gauge
8.1K
0
4
5
outside micrometer
2.4K
30
3
4
the audit

What the audit covered

Two funnel stages, benchmarked against two competitors: off-site organic and AI search, then on-site search and UX.

01
off-site search
Organic visibility diagnosis

Traced the traffic gap against Comp 1 and Comp 2 using SEMRUSH, isolating the August 2024 update as the point of collapse.

02
off-site search
Product findability gap

Benchmarked rank on high-volume generic terms to show which products are effectively invisible to search engines.

03
AI readiness
Proprietary AI readiness scoring

Ran product pages through a custom Python crawler that scores structured data against AI and agent-commerce signals.

04
on-site ux
Desktop search evaluation

Tested cross-reference and compare functionality on desktop to confirm what already works well.

05
on-site ux
Mobile friction audit

Walked mobile search and filtering end to end, flagging persistence, ordering, and layout issues.

06
on-site ux
Filter hierarchy analysis

Compared facet order against both competitors to identify where function should come before form.

the tools

What ran the audit

Competitive intelligence, a proprietary readiness scorer, and hands-on UX testing across desktop and mobile.

Competitive Intelligence
SEMRUSH

Traffic trends, keyword rankings, and competitor benchmarking.

Google Search Console

Recommended deep-dive to isolate indexing and crawl issues.

AI readiness
Proprietary AI Readiness Assessment

Python crawler that scores product pages and flags fixes for structured data and schema.

On-site & UX
Manual UX testing

Hands-on desktop and mobile search testing using real product test cases.

Search facet & filter review

Structured comparison of filter order and behavior against competitors.

proprietary tool

A Python crawler that scores AI readiness.

Structured data is what lets AI assistants accurately identify, cite, compare, and recommend products in conversational search. I built a Python tool that crawls product pages directly, then scores each one against the schema and content signals AI and agent commerce actually rely on.

The output isn't just a score, it's a prioritized list of what's missing or broken, and how to fix it. In this sample, one product page was scored; a complete audit crawls the full catalog.

Score Bands

Weighted across signals like Core Schema (10 pts), Product Identification (8 pts), and Social Proof (8 pts) — pass, warn, or fail on each.
The takeaway

The visibility gap isn't a product problem, it's a technical and navigational one, and it's fixable in weeks, not quarters.

Recapture demand across 150K+ products, fix the on-site experience on mobile and then desktop, and close the gap with competitors while building a scalable foundation for AI-driven search.

I would run this same audit — off-site search, AI readiness scoring, and on-site UX  for your site. If you want to see where you can improve, hit me up below.